Clinical Trials
Learn more about clinical trials
As well as being a clinical observational study (which is designed to study how HD happens in humans and is not testing any drugs), Enroll-HD is also a clinical research platform; this means that smaller clinical studies that are looking into certain aspects of HD in people are also connected to Enroll-HD, and these studies often use the same clinical sites and recruit people already participating in Enroll-HD. These studies might be exploring factors that influence the health of people with HD, or investigating a better way to measure the changes caused by the disease, or collecting extremely valuable research resources like cerebrospinal fluid that can give us a clearer picture of what is happening in an HD brain. When you sign up for Enroll-HD, you can choose to be contacted by your local site staff should suitable research opportunities like this become available that are looking for volunteers like you.
You may also have the chance to join a clinical trial, which usually test novel drugs to see whether they can prevent or treat a disease in people; they are sometimes called “interventional” trials, meaning that the drug being tested is a medical intervention. (These interventional trials are different from “observational” studies like Enroll-HD, which is designed to study how HD happens in humans and is not testing any drugs).
If a pharmaceutical or biotechnology company has a new HD drug that requires clinical testing in people, they usually come to Enroll-HD to help identify which clinical sites around the world are best suited to their trial. Part of this process will involve the investigators at each clinical site looking through the Enroll-HD database for people who have already said they are willing to be contacted about clinical trials. If you have agreed in your consent form to be contacted and you have the right characteristics for the trial (which will be different for each one), your neurologist or another person at the site where you get care will contact you to see if you are interested in taking part. Nobody outside your local clinical site where you go for your Enroll-HD visits will be able to see any identifying information such as your name, address or birth date.
Volunteering for any study or trial is completely up to you and is always your choice. Whatever choice you make, it won’t affect your care—you can still be part of Enroll-HD even if you don’t want to join other studies or trials.
A clinical trial is the gold-standard way to systematically test whether a new drug can provide clinical benefit to people, meaning can the new drug prevent or treat a disease in people. They are sometimes called “interventional” trials, meaning that the drug being tested is a medical intervention. (These interventional trials are different from “observational” studies like Enroll-HD, which is designed to study how HD happens in humans and is not testing any drugs). Clinical trials often test drugs, but some other kinds of treatments (such as exercise and physiotherapy regimens, or surgical procedures like deep brain stimulation) may also be tested this way.
No matter how well a new drug (or even a drug already approved for another disease) seems to work in animal models of disease, that drug needs to be tested in a large group of people to test whether it also works in humans and to find out what side effects it might cause. Since humans and animal models are very different, most potential new drugs tested in clinical trials are not approved for various reasons. However, whatever the outcome of a trial, what we learn from these human trials is often extremely important for the next round of drug development.
The major reason why clinical trials often move more slowly than patients and families would like is that safety is absolutely paramount, lots of regulations are in place to make sure everything possible is done so that research participants are not harmed. This means mountains of paperwork to check that things are being done properly and within the strictly enforced rules and regulations, for very good reasons.
Another reason is recruitment; finding enough people at the “right” stage of their disease and who are willing to volunteer for a particular clinical trial is often difficult and time-consuming, especially for rare diseases like HD.
All clinical trials conducted in the US and Europe (including trials that have clinical sites in other parts of the world) must get approval from either the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the European Medicines Agency (EMA), or both. Similarly, almost all clinical trials are also overseen by local Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) that include doctors and scientists as well as community members. All trials involve some level of risk, that’s the nature of research, but the IRBs review the protocol that sets out how the study will be conducted to make sure that the risks are reasonable and in proportion to the potential benefit. If you decide to volunteer for a clinical trial, the informed consent form that you sign before you begin will clearly spell out the potential risks and benefits—you should discuss these and any other questions with your doctor and other health professionals.
Not necessarily. Most trials don’t include complete medical care—you will still go to your regular doctors. Also, while sometimes the drug being tested is a real improvement over current alternatives, it may turn out not to be very effective, or it may cause side effects.
You should find out whether you will have to modify your current medications, and who will be responsible for your health care. It’s good to know at the outset how long the study is expected to last, although you always have the right to withdraw from any trial or study at any time for any reason.
You might ask why the research team thinks this treatment will be effective, or whether it’s been studied before. Another good question might be, if the experimental medicine works for you, will you be able to keep getting it after the study is completed?
The US National Institutes of Health has more comprehensive lists of questions you might consider asking (NIH Clinical Trials; NIH Clinical Trials and You). The UK Medical Research Council also provides more information about clinical trials.
Preclinical studies
Drugs are almost always first tested in animal models to get a sense of what the correct dosage should be, to look for dangerous side effects, and to get hints about whether it might help people with the disease.
Clinical trials
Clinical trials of drugs or treatments in humans are conducted in three phases. Clinicaltrials.gov has more information about the clinical trial process. You can also search all the current clinical trials for Huntington’s disease.
How are clinical trials structured?
The first step in human testing is Phase 1, which mainly looks at the safety of a potential drug. The drug is given to a small number of healthy people at various doses for a short time to make sure they don’t develop any serious side effects. These trials usually last several months. About 25%1 of all HD drugs and interventions tested in Phase 1 trial make it to the next step.
Phase 2 trials are designed to further evaluate safety and make sure that the drug doesn’t cause problems in a larger group of people who actually have the disease, and to look at what dose can be given to people. Often a Phase 2 trial is also designed to give an early hint about efficacy, meaning whether or not it is effective—does the drug show signs that it might be beneficial to patients? These trials typically last from several months to two years. About 20%1 of HD drugs and interventions tested in Phase 2 trials make it to the next step.
Most Phase 2 trials are very choosy about which people will be included in this stage, and often seek volunteers in a narrow age range with a specific set of symptoms and no other health problems. This is so that the analysis won’t be clouded by other factors—they want to try to isolate any effect the drug may have and keep everything else the same.
Phase 2 trials are almost always randomized and blinded, meaning that the trial participants are randomly assigned to treatment groups, with some given the active drug at different doses and others given a placebo—a sugar pill or something else known to be inactive—without anyone knowing what kind of treatment they are getting (this is the ‘blinded’ part). This is to prevent people’s hopes or subconscious biases from influencing the results. Even the staff who run the study don’t know which people are getting the experimental drug—only the people who analyze the data get to know who got what.
Phase 3 trials are the real acid test, when the drug is given to a larger and more diverse group of people. The goal is to see if the drug or treatment is effective, that is, does it offer a clinical benefit to patients and improve their course of disease or signs/symptoms. These trials usually last one to four years and also provide further safety data, monitoring for adverse reactions or side effects.
If the drug is effective, and if the side effects are not dangerous, the company or other institution sponsoring the trial will apply to regulatory authorities (like the US FDA and/or the EMA in Europe) for approval. These agencies review the data and judge whether the balance of benefit and risk to patients is reasonable. About 14%1 of the HD drugs or interventions that enter Phase 3 trials are successful and gain approval. Given the drugs that don’t make it past Phase 1 or Phase 2, that means that only about 3.5%1 of HD drugs or interventions that begin testing in humans are eventually approved and available for use by doctors for clinical use.
1 Travessa AM, Rodrigues FB, Mestre TA, Ferreira JJ. Fifteen Years of Clinical Trials in Huntington’s Disease: A Very Low Clinical Drug Development Success Rate. J Huntingtons Dis. 2017;6(2):157-163. doi: 10.3233/JHD-170245. PMID: 28671135.